Pricing psychology: 9 strategies that motivate customers to buy

On the surface, pricing your products may feel like a simple mathematical equation: you price your items so that you cover your costs and make a profit. However, pricing can also serve as a powerful marketing tool in and of itself. A product’s price can communicate quite a bit to your customers and can be a tool to help push them toward making a purchase.

In this article, we’ll explore nine battle-tested psychological techniques you can use to set the perfect prices in your eCommerce store. The goal with each of these techniques is to turn your price into a sales asset—one that appeals to your customers and helps motivate them to click through your email or click the “Add to cart” button on your site and buy.

1. Charm pricing vs. prestige pricing

Charm pricing is the oldest pricing trick in the book: you make a tiny reduction in a product’s price to change its leftmost digit (e.g., $20 to $19.99). Even though the product’s price has barely changed, it looks and feels so much lower.

Charm pricing in a Target ad.

The reason you see so many products with charm pricing is because it’s effective; one study found conversion rates more than doubled with a one-cent reduction from $2 to $1.99. 

However, there is a potential downside of charm pricing: it’s not a universal solution. It works really well for items where price is a primary consideration (think: food at grocery stores, anything at big box retailers, or, perhaps the ultimate example, everything at 99-cent only stores). But not every product decision we make is based on price. 

This is where prestige pricing comes in. Prestige pricing is a much more straightforward approach, where a store uses a simple dollar value to convey quality and even social status. When you’re at a nice restaurant, the filet mignon isn’t listed at $59.99. It’s listed at $60.

Charm pricing appeals to us on an analytical basis, while prestige pricing appeals to us on an emotional one. One study confirmed that when the context of the purchase decision (logical versus emotional) matches the pricing strategy (charm or prestige, respectively), the result is a purchase that just “feels right.”

Luxury brands clearly aren’t selling their products to satisfy a logical necessity; does a $30,000 gas range really perform 10 times better than a $3,000 gas range? Instead, they’re tapping into the feelings and emotions of wealth and/or aspiration, where customers care about how material belongings reflect on their status. These customers are more likely to “feel right” about their purchase—and make additional purchases in the future—if the pricing itself aligns with their innermost motivations. They won’t be motivated because the gas range costs $29,999 instead of $30,000—they’ll be motivated by the idea that they have a $30,000 gas range in their state-of-the-art kitchen.

Feelings-based pricing doesn’t just work on high-end products either. In this example from Carter’s, an array of summer products are offered for $5 and up—not $4.99 and up. They don’t want your logical mind to step in and start thinking about price. They want your emotional mind to say, “Well, $5 is cool so I don’t need to bother using mental energy on the price, I’m mostly excited about having something new to wear by the pool.”

Round number pricing isn't just for expensive products.

2. Buy-one-get-one

Buy-one-get-one (BOGO) shares some similarities with charm pricing: it’s as familiar to customers as it is to marketers, and it’s been around seemingly forever. BOGO comes in many variations: buy-one-get-one-free, buy-one-get-two-free, buy-one-get-one-half-off, etc. 

A BOGO sale.

BOGO deals appeal to customers because of the power of the word “free.” A study found most people will opt for a free product over a heavily-discounted—but better—product (for example, we’d take a free Hershey’s Kiss over a 15-cent imported Swiss truffle). 

In addition, BOGO deals allow you to run appealing promotions without explicitly discounting your prices. You can sell the original item at full price and full margin. That helps you absorb the cost of throwing in the second product free and avoids devaluing your products in the eyes of your customer.

If you sell a $40 shirt and your customer gets another $40 shirt for free, that keeps the perception of your products more valuable than if you’d run a 50 percent off sale so your customer got two $20 shirts. In both cases, they spent $40 and got two shirts—but the perceived value of your products only remains high in the first scenario. 

One other strong case for BOGO pricing: customers really like it. A study found 66 percent of customers say BOGO deals are their favorite type of promotions and 93 percent have taken advantage of one. (PDF

3.  Comparative pricing

Comparative pricing is a little more subtle than the above concepts. The basic idea is to offer two products simultaneously, but deliberately make one product’s price more attractive than the other.

This strategy can be employed by premium brands to encourage customers to pick the ostensibly higher-quality, higher-status product.

It can also be used by more modest brands to highlight their affordability in contrast to name brands. This technique is common practice with large retailers’ store brands like Target’s Up & Up, Amazon’s AmazonBasics line, or generic grocery store items. (Who doesn’t love saving money by getting a big bag of Charms That Are Lucky cereal?)

Studies have shown, however, that comparative pricing requires a lot of care or it can backfire, in part because of the phenomenon of explicit versus implicit comparisons.

Explicit comparisons are those that are highlighted and advertised by the seller. For example, store brands will print explicit comparisons directly on their products—CVS frequently works “compare to active ingredients in X brand” into the packaging for their own over-the-counter items.

CVS OTC products use comparative pricing.

Implicit comparisons are those that customers will make themselves, often in direct contradiction to a brand’s best efforts. For instance, a customer may see that the store brand is cheaper and instantly come to the conclusion it’s lower quality.

So when you use comparative pricing, make sure you’re doing it in such a way that your copy positions your product how you want it to be positioned.

4. Price anchoring

Price anchoring is the strategic use of one price to influence how the customer perceives additional prices in the same advertisement. The anchor price effectively provides a frame of reference for the sale price.

Sometimes price anchoring is as simple as using strikethrough on the anchor price and placing the sale price right next to it (for example, $100 $75). 

Price anchoring at work.

It’s worth noting that anchoring is only effective in the long term if you normally do sell your products at the original price. Your customers may become numb to the effect of anchoring if your products are perpetually selling for the stated “sale” price. As always, a sale should feel exceptional and urgent to your customers; otherwise, your promotions are more likely to fall flat.

5. Decoy pricing

A close cousin to price anchoring is decoy pricing. That’s where you offer multiple options and intentionally make one so unappealing it makes the option you really want customers to choose look even more appealing.

A famous example comes from a subscription pricing experiment by The Economist. They sold subscriptions to their print magazine, the online version of their magazine, or both.

Subscription pricing options at the Economist.

The online-only subscription was priced at $59, print-only was $125, and print and web together were also offered at $125. A test with that model found 84 percent of people opted for the combo deal—which is the desired outcome—and 16 percent opted for the cheaper online-only option. No one took the print-only option.

Then the pricing structure was altered. The $125 print-only option was removed, leaving only the online subscription at $59 or the print and web subscription at $125. The results were a disaster: now 68 percent of people opted for the inexpensive online-only option. 

That’s what happens by removing the decoy, which was the totally unappealing $125 print-only option. That option’s presence made the $125 print-and-web option seem like a far better value and pushed the overwhelming majority of people toward it. When the decoy was gone, suddenly the cheaper option became the most attractive—and that was bad for business.

6. Magnitude representation congruency

Besides being one heck of a mouthful, magnitude representation congruency is the psychologically-sound way of saying “size matters.”

It may seem like an obvious choice to highlight a sale price by increasing its font size in a marketing email or an ad. However, magnitude representation congruency asserts a marketer’s best psychological bet is for the font size of the price to correspond to the dollar value of the price. In other words, smaller price + smaller font size = happy brains!

A multi-faceted study in the Journal of Consumer Psychology found “[presenting] lower sale prices in a relatively small font resulted in more favorable value assessments and greater purchase likelihood or choice than presenting … lower sale prices in a relatively large font.” (PDF)

It’s also worth noting there may be a second reason why small price displays are more appealing: a large font may be a turn-off for customers who are constantly inundated with aggressive advertising.

7. Price framing

Persuasive language can help frame a customer’s perception of your pricing. If you’ve ever heard of something described as “the cost of a cup of coffee,” that’s price framing—rather than think about a $4 price tag, you instead think of the cost as the amount of money you happily spend, with no hesitation, on something as disposable and fleeting as a cup of coffee.

Another example of using language to frame a price is saying “as low as $X” or “only $X”—suddenly, the product magically feels like more of a bargain.

Staples uses "as low as" price framing.

Language can also impact a customer’s perception of your pricing even when the words aren’t in direct reference to your pricing. The study from the Journal of Consumer Psychology found that perceptions of pricing for inline skates changed when the skates themselves were described as “low friction” versus “high performance.” Customers were more likely to buy the stakes when the word “low” was present—“low friction” actually made customers instinctively think “low price.” 

8. Innumerancy

Spell check informs us that innumerancy is not yet a word. Psychologists would tend to disagree.

Innumerancy is one of the more cynical psychological concepts you can employ in your marketing. The basic gist is that people are bad at math, and brands can use that to their advantage.

Play with the numbers in your sales to position them so they look as appealing as possible—often, bigger numbers for discounts work better. A 30 percent off sale can look more appealing than a $5 off coupon, even if the latter is more lucrative on any product under $17. Going back to our BOGO section, buy-one-get-one-free is really 50 percent off two items—but it’s being framed as 100 percent off one item. “100 percent off” and “free” look more appealing than “50 percent off two items”—even though they’re the same exact deal.

Innumerancy can be particularly relevant for brands that sell any kind of subscription service. If your price for a subscription is $180-per-year, you may be better off calling that $15-per-month for the simple fact that it seems like a lower price at first glance. That might just be the reason why we all have so many memberships to subscription services going—after all, I can afford to add Disney+, Peacock, HBO Max, and everything else (but probably not Quibi) to my arsenal, their monthly prices are all so low. Right?

9. Emphasize time spent over money saved

Sometimes the best way to advertise a price is not to advertise the price at all. Psychologically speaking, there are some things that are (in certain circumstances) much more powerful motivators for customers than simple economics. One of them is time; that is, time spent using your product to have a good time with friends and family.

One study examined this idea from a few different angles and found three explanations for why time is so powerful in marketing:

  1. Time is less easily replaced than money; as the saying goes, you can’t make up for lost time. Thus, tapping into a person’s desire to make the most of their time with friends and family (or even quiet time alone) can result in marketing that truly resonates.
  2. Time is ambiguous and more difficult to quantify than money, so people feel less accountable for how they spend their time—in contrast to money, which most people monitor constantly. This opens an avenue for marketers to tap into a person’s deepest desires for how they’d ideally want to spend their time.
  3. For most people, how they spend their time is more of a reflection of their personal experiences, identity, and emotions. Locating the potential intersection of your product and a customer’s identity and emotions is immensely powerful and likely more motivating than a desire to save a few bucks.

The following example from YETI emphasizes concepts like finding new adventures and “longer hangs” with friends. They’re not selling this cooler or cup based on their prices; they’re making the price come secondary to the experiences the products can unlock. In fact, if they did include the prices here, it might distract from the message. YETI products are relatively expensive in their category (the cooler is $200, the mug is $30), so they’re opting for the emotional hook to get people invested—whereas a high price might make the logical side of people’s brains ignore the intangible benefits and just feel sticker shock.

YETI uses emotional appeals.

Key takeaways

Pricing is a powerful marketing tool—everything from the specific digits you choose to the way your price is displayed in advertisements can impact how your prices are perceived. There are a number of useful psychological theories and strategies that can be incorporated into your pricing to help boost your conversions. 

  • Charm pricing is the official term for lowering a product’s price a tiny bit in order to lower the first digit of the price by one. Especially with lower-priced items, a reduction in price by one cent can feel like a much bigger discount than it really is. Prestige pricing is a more straightforward approach to pricing, utilizing a simple, rounded numeric price to appeal to the emotional part of someone’s brain.
  • Buy-one-get-one is a classic pricing strategy that’s especially well-suited for limited time offers with specific deadlines. It’s a popular deal with customers and can help you avoid the pitfall of a discount hurting your products’ perceived value.
  • Comparative pricing is the placing two similar items next to each other but deliberately making one’s price seem relatively more attractive.
  • Anchoring presents a high price to make a lower price seem even better.
  • Decoy pricing is a more deliberate attempt to steer customers in a specific direction by offering a buffet of options, with one option being so bad that it encourages customers to pick the desired option as an obviously superior alternative.
  • Magnitude representation congruency is the theory that a price should be visually depicted so it’s consistent its cost. The price will “feel right” if there is congruency between its value and the font size used.
  • Price framing involves using persuasive copy like “as low as” and “only” to help influence a customer’s perception of your pricing as a good deal.
  • Innumerancy is the idea that people are generally bad at math, and that can be used to a marketer’s advantage. So make your discounts look as large as possible to make them more appealing.
  • Emphasizing time spent over money saved is a great way to tap into a customer’s personal identity, emotions, and motivations. While money can be a primary motivator for virtually every customer, the concept of time gets to the heart of what deeply matters to people.
Matt Maggiacomo
Matt Maggiacomo is a writer, digital fundraiser, and musician with over four years of executive-level experience in nonprofit management. He has been utilizing digital technology to promote his creative projects since 2001 and is the founder of the creative consultancy Pitch & Prose.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *